Impact of High Deductible Health Plans on U.S. Adults With Chronic Pain

Introduction: Chronic pain affects an estimated 20% of U.S. adults. Because high-deductible health plans have captured a growing share of the commercial insurance market, it is unknown how high-deductible health plans impact care for chronic pain. Methods: Using 2007–2017 claims data from a large national commercial insurer, statistical analyses conducted in 2022–2023 estimated changes in enrollee outcomes before and after their firm began offering a high-deductible health plan compared with changes in outcomes in a comparison group of enrollees at firms never offering a high-deductible health plan. The sample included 757,530 commercially insured adults aged 18–64 years with headache, low back pain, arthritis, neuropathic pain, or fibromyalgia. Outcomes, measured at the enrollee year level, included the probability of receiving any chronic pain treatment, nonpharmacologic pain treatment, and opioid and nonopioid prescriptions; the number of nonpharmacologic pain treatment days; number and days’ supply of opioid and nonopioid prescriptions; and total annual spending and out-of-pocket spending. Results: High-deductible health plan offer was associated with a 1.2 percentage point reduction (95% CI= −1.8, −0.5) in the probability of any chronic pain treatment and an $11 increase (95% CI=$6, $15) in annual out-of-pocket spending on chronic pain treatments among those with any use, representing a 16% increase in average annual out-of-pocket spending over the pre−high deductible health plan offer annual average. Results were driven by changes in nonpharmacologic treatment use. Conclusions: By reducing the use of nonpharmacologic chronic pain treatments and marginally increasing out-of-pocket costs among those using these services, high-deductible health plans may discourage more holistic, integrated approaches to caring for patients with chronic pain conditions.