TY - GEN
T1 - Impact of cone-beam CT noise correlation on self-supervised denoising strategies for low dose breast CT imaging
AU - Sisniega Crespo, Alejandro
AU - Íñigo, B.
AU - Hernandez, A. M.
AU - McGraw, J.
AU - Achkire, Y.
AU - Siewerdsen, J. H.
AU - Boone, J. M.
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© COPYRIGHT SPIE. Downloading of the abstract is permitted for personal use only.
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - Cone-beam breast CT (bCT) provides volumetric images of the uncompressed breast but present higher noise than 2D mammography. Deep Learning (DL) denoising with supervised training has shown successful CBCT noise reduction but requires matched low-dose and high-dose images. Self-supervised training removes that requirement but often assume locally independent noise. This work studies the impact of bCT noise correlation on self-supervised denoising methods. The self-supervised training strategies included two blind spot methods - Noise2Self, enforcing local similarity with independent image noise; and Noise2Sim, enforcing image similarity in presence of correlated noise - and two Noisier2Noise approaches: i) noise injection in the image domain; and, ii) noise injection in projection domain with a model of noise correlation. Self-supervised training was performed on bCT images generated from 150 voxelized models with a high-fidelity forward projector, including models of the x-ray spectrum, polychromatic attenuation, and detector signal and noise propagation. Denoised images were assessed with respect to high-dose references and supervised denoising, using RMSE, SSIM, and noise power spectrum (NPS). Noise2Sim and Noisier2Noise with noise injection in the projection domain showed good performance in presence of correlated noise, achieving RMSE of 0.21 and 0.18 (SSIM of 0.9 and 0.94), respectively, compared to RMSE of 0.17 (SSIM of 0.93) for supervised training. The independent noise assumption in Noise2Self and Noisier2Noise with image domain noise injection resulted in significantly diminished performance, yielding RMSE of 0.23 and 0.37 (SSIM of 0.86 and 0.84). The NPS measurements revealed a shift towards low frequency components for Noise2Sim, arising from blurring of tissue boundaries and residual image transfer induced by the masking of dissimilar regions in the loss function. Noisier2Noise showed a frequency distribution of noise closer to the high-dose reference. Such performance was slightly degraded for non-matched noise injection models inducing shorter correlation kernels than the nominal detector noise correlation, but models inducing longer correlation showed negligible impact in the denoising results. Self-supervised denoising in presence of correlated noise was proved feasible. Among the evaluated models, Noisier2Noise strategies with projection domain noise injection showed denoising performance comparable to supervised training and noise spectral distribution comparable to high-dose bCT.
AB - Cone-beam breast CT (bCT) provides volumetric images of the uncompressed breast but present higher noise than 2D mammography. Deep Learning (DL) denoising with supervised training has shown successful CBCT noise reduction but requires matched low-dose and high-dose images. Self-supervised training removes that requirement but often assume locally independent noise. This work studies the impact of bCT noise correlation on self-supervised denoising methods. The self-supervised training strategies included two blind spot methods - Noise2Self, enforcing local similarity with independent image noise; and Noise2Sim, enforcing image similarity in presence of correlated noise - and two Noisier2Noise approaches: i) noise injection in the image domain; and, ii) noise injection in projection domain with a model of noise correlation. Self-supervised training was performed on bCT images generated from 150 voxelized models with a high-fidelity forward projector, including models of the x-ray spectrum, polychromatic attenuation, and detector signal and noise propagation. Denoised images were assessed with respect to high-dose references and supervised denoising, using RMSE, SSIM, and noise power spectrum (NPS). Noise2Sim and Noisier2Noise with noise injection in the projection domain showed good performance in presence of correlated noise, achieving RMSE of 0.21 and 0.18 (SSIM of 0.9 and 0.94), respectively, compared to RMSE of 0.17 (SSIM of 0.93) for supervised training. The independent noise assumption in Noise2Self and Noisier2Noise with image domain noise injection resulted in significantly diminished performance, yielding RMSE of 0.23 and 0.37 (SSIM of 0.86 and 0.84). The NPS measurements revealed a shift towards low frequency components for Noise2Sim, arising from blurring of tissue boundaries and residual image transfer induced by the masking of dissimilar regions in the loss function. Noisier2Noise showed a frequency distribution of noise closer to the high-dose reference. Such performance was slightly degraded for non-matched noise injection models inducing shorter correlation kernels than the nominal detector noise correlation, but models inducing longer correlation showed negligible impact in the denoising results. Self-supervised denoising in presence of correlated noise was proved feasible. Among the evaluated models, Noisier2Noise strategies with projection domain noise injection showed denoising performance comparable to supervised training and noise spectral distribution comparable to high-dose bCT.
KW - Breast CT
KW - Deep Learning denoising
KW - cone-beam CT
KW - noise models
KW - unsupervised learning
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85160686265&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85160686265&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1117/12.2654447
DO - 10.1117/12.2654447
M3 - Conference contribution
AN - SCOPUS:85160686265
T3 - Progress in Biomedical Optics and Imaging - Proceedings of SPIE
BT - Medical Imaging 2023
A2 - Yu, Lifeng
A2 - Fahrig, Rebecca
A2 - Sabol, John M.
PB - SPIE
T2 - Medical Imaging 2023: Physics of Medical Imaging
Y2 - 19 February 2023 through 23 February 2023
ER -